< All insights & articles

Is copyright relationship property? The Supreme Court says yes

Published on
November 23, 2026
Written by

Most people understand that the family home, savings and investments may need to be divided when a relationship ends. But relationship property can extend to less obvious assets, including property created through one partner’s own skill and creativity.

A recent Supreme Court decision confirms that copyright created during a relationship can form part of the relationship property pool. The decision has implications not only for artists, but potentially for anyone who creates valuable intellectual property through their work.

In Alalääkkölä v Palmer [2025] NZSC 9, the Supreme Court considered whether the copyright in paintings created by an artist during her marriage was relationship property under the Property (Relationships) Act 1976 (PRA). The Court’s answer was clear: copyright is property for the purposes of the PRA, and it may be relationship property.

The facts

Ms Alalääkkölä and Mr Palmer married in 1997 and separated in 2017. Ms Alalääkkölä is an accomplished, internationally trained artist, and her paintings were the family’s principal source of income during the marriage. Mr Palmer, a photographer and web designer, said he scaled back his own work to support her art career and described himself as a partner in the family business, “Art by Sirpa”.

At separation there was a large stock of unsold paintings (as many as 250) created during the relationship. It was not in dispute that the physical paintings were relationship property. The fight was over the copyright in them. Ms Alalääkkölä argued that copyright was not “property” at all for PRA purposes or, alternatively, that it was her separate property. Her concerns were real: at one stage Mr Palmer had said he intended to set up a business reproducing and selling copies of her work, and she feared her market would be flooded with cheap merchandise to the detriment of her reputation. By the time the case reached the Supreme Court, Mr Palmer’s position had softened. He accepted that she should retain ownership in the copyright, provided he received his portion of the economic benefit of the commercialisation of the paintings and associated copyright.

The path to the Supreme Court

The Family Court held that copyright in the paintings was Ms Alalääkkölä’s separate property. The High Court disagreed and held that the copyright was relationship property to be divided equally. The Court of Appeal agreed with the High Court, holding that the copyright should remain in Ms Alalääkkölä’s legal ownership, with a compensating adjustment from other relationship property to achieve an equal division. Ms Alalääkkölä appealed to the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court’s decision

The Supreme Court unanimously dismissed the appeal. The reasons, given by Miller J, addressed two questions.

Is copyright “property” under the PRA? Yes. The Copyright Act 1994 expressly describes copyright as a property right, which can be assigned, passed on by will and enforced by the owner through the courts. The Copyright Act also draws a clear line between those economic rights and the author’s moral rights (such as the right to be identified as the author and to object to derogatory treatment of the work), which stay with the author and cannot be assigned. The appellant’s argument that copyright is a product of the artist’s personality, and so not property, was in effect an attempt to merge two sets of rights that Parliament had deliberately kept apart. The Court said that would require a clear justification in the PRA, and none was apparent. Copyright fits comfortably within the PRA’s broad definition of “property” as “personal property”, and there is no reason to exclude intangible property from that definition.

Is it relationship property? Yes, where it is acquired during the relationship. The appellant argued that copyright is “created”, not “acquired”, and that it flowed from skills she had developed before the marriage. The Court rejected both points. “Acquire” in ordinary usage is wide enough to cover things a person makes, and the PRA elsewhere contemplates property “created” during a relationship being relationship property. In any event, the creative work went into the paintings themselves; the copyright attached to them by operation of law when they were created. The Court also drew a distinction between personal skills, which are not property, and the use of those skills during the relationship to create something that is. On the facts, Ms Alalääkkölä was the family’s income earner, and it was reasonable to infer that much of the unsold stock reflected the need to paint in quantity to support the family.

Valuation and the artist’s interests. Importantly, the Court did not leave the artist without protection. It recognised that an artist’s right to decide whether and when a work is shown to the public should be respected, so far as that is consistent with a just division. It adopted Ms Alalääkkölä’s own four categories of work (incomplete or damaged works, her private collection, one-off originals and works intended for reproduction) and gave guidance on how each should be valued, including that private works may be valued on the basis that they will never be sold. The case was sent back to the Family Court to determine value and distribution.

Our view: the right decision, and an obvious one

In my view, the Supreme Court could not realistically have reached any other result. The appellant’s case asked the Court to read into the PRA an exception that simply is not there. Nothing in the Copyright Act or the PRA supports treating copyright as something other than property, and the PRA’s definition of property is deliberately broad. Nor is there any general principle of property law that excludes intangible rights from being property, or that treats something as separate property merely because it is the fruit of skills a person developed or acquired before the relationship began. If that were the rule, a great deal of what couples build during a relationship (a business, a professional practice, a body of work) would fall outside the PRA. As the Court observed, a principle of that kind could not easily be confined to artistic works.

That is not to say the appellant’s position lacks sympathy. Artistic works are often deeply personal to the artist, and the idea of sharing the value of that work with a former partner may feel unfair. But the same could be said of almost any endeavour into which someone has poured their blood, sweat and tears: the founder who built a company from nothing, the professional who spent years building a client base, or the tradesperson whose skill created a successful business. The PRA’s starting point is that property acquired during the relationship is shared, because the relationship is treated as a partnership to which both people contribute in different ways. An artist’s work is no exception.

It is also worth remembering what the decision does not do. It does not hand the artist’s copyright to the other partner. The Court emphasised that orders should be designed to minimise conflict and avoid unnecessary harm to the author’s future reputation and income, and the likely outcome here is that Ms Alalääkkölä retains the copyright, with Mr Palmer compensated from other relationship property.

The takeaway: plan ahead with a contracting out agreement

The practical lesson is a simple one. If there is property you want to keep out of the relationship property pool, whether that is your creative work, a business, a family inheritance or anything else, the time to deal with it is before a dispute arises. The Supreme Court itself noted that an author concerned about a relationship property claim can insist on contracting out under section 21 of the PRA.

In New Zealand this is done through a contracting out agreement, sometimes called a “section 21 agreement” or, colloquially, a “pre-nup”. Couples can enter into one before or during a marriage, civil union or de facto relationship, and it can record that particular property, such as copyright in works created during the relationship, will be one partner’s separate property.

To be binding, a contracting out agreement must meet strict formal requirements. Among other things, it must be in writing and signed by both parties, and each party must receive independent legal advice before signing, with their lawyer witnessing their signature and certifying that the effect and implications of the agreement were explained. Even then, a court can set aside an agreement if giving effect to it would cause serious injustice. Careful drafting, and keeping the agreement under review as circumstances change, is therefore essential.

If you are an artist, writer, designer or anyone else whose work or business represents a significant part of your wealth, and you would like to discuss how to protect it, please get in touch.

‍

This is some text inside of a div block.
Peter Fuscic
Partner
Trust, Estate & Relationship Property Disputes
MOB:  
021 729 322
E:
This is some text inside of a div block.
Email
No items found.
© McVeagh Fleming 2026
This article is published for general information purposes only.  Legal content in this article is necessarily of a general nature and should not be relied upon as legal advice.  If you require specific legal advice in respect of any legal issue, you should always engage a lawyer to provide that advice.

View all Insights

Is copyright relationship property? The Supreme Court says yes

Is copyright relationship property? The Supreme Court says yes

Most people understand that the family home, savings and investments may need to be divided when a relationship ends. But relationship property can extend to less obvious assets, including property created through one partner’s own skill and creativity.

A recent Supreme Court decision confirms that copyright created during a relationship can form part of the relationship property pool. The decision has implications not only for artists, but potentially for anyone who creates valuable intellectual property through their work.

In Alalääkkölä v Palmer [2025] NZSC 9, the Supreme Court considered whether the copyright in paintings created by an artist during her marriage was relationship property under the Property (Relationships) Act 1976 (PRA). The Court’s answer was clear: copyright is property for the purposes of the PRA, and it may be relationship property.

The facts

Ms Alalääkkölä and Mr Palmer married in 1997 and separated in 2017. Ms Alalääkkölä is an accomplished, internationally trained artist, and her paintings were the family’s principal source of income during the marriage. Mr Palmer, a photographer and web designer, said he scaled back his own work to support her art career and described himself as a partner in the family business, “Art by Sirpa”.

At separation there was a large stock of unsold paintings (as many as 250) created during the relationship. It was not in dispute that the physical paintings were relationship property. The fight was over the copyright in them. Ms Alalääkkölä argued that copyright was not “property” at all for PRA purposes or, alternatively, that it was her separate property. Her concerns were real: at one stage Mr Palmer had said he intended to set up a business reproducing and selling copies of her work, and she feared her market would be flooded with cheap merchandise to the detriment of her reputation. By the time the case reached the Supreme Court, Mr Palmer’s position had softened. He accepted that she should retain ownership in the copyright, provided he received his portion of the economic benefit of the commercialisation of the paintings and associated copyright.

The path to the Supreme Court

The Family Court held that copyright in the paintings was Ms Alalääkkölä’s separate property. The High Court disagreed and held that the copyright was relationship property to be divided equally. The Court of Appeal agreed with the High Court, holding that the copyright should remain in Ms Alalääkkölä’s legal ownership, with a compensating adjustment from other relationship property to achieve an equal division. Ms Alalääkkölä appealed to the Supreme Court.

The Supreme Court’s decision

The Supreme Court unanimously dismissed the appeal. The reasons, given by Miller J, addressed two questions.

Is copyright “property” under the PRA? Yes. The Copyright Act 1994 expressly describes copyright as a property right, which can be assigned, passed on by will and enforced by the owner through the courts. The Copyright Act also draws a clear line between those economic rights and the author’s moral rights (such as the right to be identified as the author and to object to derogatory treatment of the work), which stay with the author and cannot be assigned. The appellant’s argument that copyright is a product of the artist’s personality, and so not property, was in effect an attempt to merge two sets of rights that Parliament had deliberately kept apart. The Court said that would require a clear justification in the PRA, and none was apparent. Copyright fits comfortably within the PRA’s broad definition of “property” as “personal property”, and there is no reason to exclude intangible property from that definition.

Is it relationship property? Yes, where it is acquired during the relationship. The appellant argued that copyright is “created”, not “acquired”, and that it flowed from skills she had developed before the marriage. The Court rejected both points. “Acquire” in ordinary usage is wide enough to cover things a person makes, and the PRA elsewhere contemplates property “created” during a relationship being relationship property. In any event, the creative work went into the paintings themselves; the copyright attached to them by operation of law when they were created. The Court also drew a distinction between personal skills, which are not property, and the use of those skills during the relationship to create something that is. On the facts, Ms Alalääkkölä was the family’s income earner, and it was reasonable to infer that much of the unsold stock reflected the need to paint in quantity to support the family.

Valuation and the artist’s interests. Importantly, the Court did not leave the artist without protection. It recognised that an artist’s right to decide whether and when a work is shown to the public should be respected, so far as that is consistent with a just division. It adopted Ms Alalääkkölä’s own four categories of work (incomplete or damaged works, her private collection, one-off originals and works intended for reproduction) and gave guidance on how each should be valued, including that private works may be valued on the basis that they will never be sold. The case was sent back to the Family Court to determine value and distribution.

Our view: the right decision, and an obvious one

In my view, the Supreme Court could not realistically have reached any other result. The appellant’s case asked the Court to read into the PRA an exception that simply is not there. Nothing in the Copyright Act or the PRA supports treating copyright as something other than property, and the PRA’s definition of property is deliberately broad. Nor is there any general principle of property law that excludes intangible rights from being property, or that treats something as separate property merely because it is the fruit of skills a person developed or acquired before the relationship began. If that were the rule, a great deal of what couples build during a relationship (a business, a professional practice, a body of work) would fall outside the PRA. As the Court observed, a principle of that kind could not easily be confined to artistic works.

That is not to say the appellant’s position lacks sympathy. Artistic works are often deeply personal to the artist, and the idea of sharing the value of that work with a former partner may feel unfair. But the same could be said of almost any endeavour into which someone has poured their blood, sweat and tears: the founder who built a company from nothing, the professional who spent years building a client base, or the tradesperson whose skill created a successful business. The PRA’s starting point is that property acquired during the relationship is shared, because the relationship is treated as a partnership to which both people contribute in different ways. An artist’s work is no exception.

It is also worth remembering what the decision does not do. It does not hand the artist’s copyright to the other partner. The Court emphasised that orders should be designed to minimise conflict and avoid unnecessary harm to the author’s future reputation and income, and the likely outcome here is that Ms Alalääkkölä retains the copyright, with Mr Palmer compensated from other relationship property.

The takeaway: plan ahead with a contracting out agreement

The practical lesson is a simple one. If there is property you want to keep out of the relationship property pool, whether that is your creative work, a business, a family inheritance or anything else, the time to deal with it is before a dispute arises. The Supreme Court itself noted that an author concerned about a relationship property claim can insist on contracting out under section 21 of the PRA.

In New Zealand this is done through a contracting out agreement, sometimes called a “section 21 agreement” or, colloquially, a “pre-nup”. Couples can enter into one before or during a marriage, civil union or de facto relationship, and it can record that particular property, such as copyright in works created during the relationship, will be one partner’s separate property.

To be binding, a contracting out agreement must meet strict formal requirements. Among other things, it must be in writing and signed by both parties, and each party must receive independent legal advice before signing, with their lawyer witnessing their signature and certifying that the effect and implications of the agreement were explained. Even then, a court can set aside an agreement if giving effect to it would cause serious injustice. Careful drafting, and keeping the agreement under review as circumstances change, is therefore essential.

If you are an artist, writer, designer or anyone else whose work or business represents a significant part of your wealth, and you would like to discuss how to protect it, please get in touch.

‍

Subscribe to receive updates

I would like to receive updates for:
Thank you for subscribing. Your submission has been received!
Oops! Something went wrong while submitting the form. Please try again.